Cooking and Food

Pesto In a Mortar and Pestle

Pesto that holds together like a sauce. No separating into oil and bits.

My parents never bought into the idea of a food processor with its spinning blade whipping and chopping whatever was in the bowl. As a kid, I thought it was the latest and greatest of kitchen gadgets and wanted them to get one. Moving out with my girlfriend, we ended up getting one from a warehouse sale of a catalogue photograph company unloading their wares.

We use it but with the age of the internet upon us and digital photos and videos, the stuff I made in that food processor looked pale compared to what others were manually making by chopping and grinding.

Pesto is no exception and does extremely well… Far better in a mortar and pestle than in a food processor.

Quick and simple with a good heavy one, here’s my process.

Pine nuts and garlic with a bit of kosher or large flake sea salt.
Pound and grind for a few seconds until you get a paste. If it takes longer than 10-20 seconds and the contents keep escaping, it’s not a good mortar and pestle.
Add your basil and continue. I use stems too and it takes a little more time to grind down.
A nice pesto paste so far.
Grating some Parmesan for taste and bringing it together more.
Mix it up
Some olive oil to loosen the mixture up.

And that is it.

As far as quantity of ingredients go, there really isn’t any in mine. Same rules of thumb apply as far as knowing what each ingredient tastes like and adjusting to taste.

  • Garlic
  • Pine nuts (can be toasted)
  • Large crystal salt (kosher, sea salt, etc)
  • Italian basil leaves
  • Parmesan cheese grated
  • Olive oil